*DISCLAIMER ALERT: This blog is for my soc 490 class and therefore it will have no relevance to what I did this past week. You may proceed if you wish*
This past week in Soc 490, we began discussing whether healthcare is a right or a privilege. After reading four sections out of the Universal Health Care book, I decided that I think healthcare is a privilege. If healthcare is in fact a privilege then there does not have to be a Universal Health Care plan in effect. The four authors in Universal Health Care that we read were Helen Redmond, Leonard Peikoff, Mark Creech, and the interfaith center in corporate responsibility. Redmond believes that Healthcare is a right while Peikoff believes it is a privilege.
I believe that healthcare is a privilege and not a right because it is not outlined in the constitution. The constitution states that we have the right to life, liberty, property, and the pursuit of happiness. There is no statement saying we have the right to healthcare. Peikoff says that these “American rights impose no obligations on other people, merely the negative obligation to leave you alone.” Peikoff is saying that we were given these rights because they do not impose on others rights. If you want property you have the right to work for it and if you want the pursuit of happiness you have the right to try to obtain it. Just like the constitution states, we have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness not healthcare. I look at healthcare as a reward to hard-work.
An example that Peikoff uses to explain his point is haircare. If you were born with the right to free haircare then you would be taking away the rights of hair dressers. This is the same thing when applied to free healthcare. When providing universal healthcare for others the government would be taking away the right of doctors and nurses. Although haircare and healthcare are different, the point is that if they were free someone’s rights or freedom is being imposed upon. I also believe that healthcare is a privilege because it is a reward for things that you may have accomplished. If you work everyday and make a good living then you should have the opportunity to get healthcare. If you sit and home everyday and don’t try to earn a living then you shouldn’t be entitled to healthcare. I don’t believe it should be handed to someone just because they want it to be. I think if we work towards something it should be available to us.
